Frequently Asked Questions

Please note that the information on this page is not current

On May 27, 2025, the City Council decided to first establish its own frameworks for the reception of asylum seekers in Aalten. The college of mayor and aldermen awaits those frameworks before taking further steps.

The information on this website is based on the previously proposed plan. Therefore, it is not quite correct now. We do leave the pages online so you can read back what has been shared so far.

If there is new information, we will update this website.

You may have questions about the arrival of a reception location for asylum seekers in Aalten. Below we answer the most frequently asked questions. Is your question not listed? Please contact us via opvang@aalten.nl. The questions and answers are updated regularly. You can recognize new questions by the date behind the question.

Questions about decision-making

What did the college decide (22-05-2025)?

The College of Mayor and Aldermen decided:

  1. To agree to the realization of an AZC in the municipality.
  2. To agree to the - undeveloped - site at Singelweg in Aalten as a location for an AZC.
  3. Agree to a full-fledged AZC consisting of 300 reception spaces with services under the full responsibility of COA.
  4. To agree to the drafting of a Declaration of Intent between the college and COA, as a basis for the long-term administrative establishment of the five conditions set by the municipality in the realization of an AZC with 300 reception places on the following topics:
    4.1 (Youth) health care
    4.2 Educational housing
    4.3 The possible building of excess capacity for other target groups such as status holders
    4.4 An above-ground and underground infrastructure that can be utilized after the departure of the AZC for the intended new residential area
    4.5 Leaving behind a service center that can be used for the benefit of the community after the departure of the AZC
    4.6 The COA will ensure that part of the couplers (status holders to be housed in Aalten) come from the Aalten reception site itself.
  5. Agree to an operating period of up to 10 years after which the AZC will be dissolved and leave the municipality.

All agreements between the college and COA are recorded in an Administrative Agreement. This is preceded by a letter of intent between the college and COA, in which the basic agreements as mentioned above are described. The practical elaboration of the five aforementioned conditions are laid down in the document
"Working Arrangements" that is attached to the Administrative Agreement as an addendum. This will also include agreements relating to security at and outside the AZC and other relevant topics that emerge from discussions with residents.

See further: College proposal AZC (pages 6 to 18)

Why didn't we know this before/why weren't we involved beforehand? (16-05-2025)

We understand that you are wondering why you were not informed or involved sooner. The municipality has had several sites investigated recently. Only when it became clear that this site is suitable and other sites are not suitable or not available, were we able to go public about it. Earlier, there was too much uncertainty.  

We wanted to avoid unrest about places that ultimately wouldn't be. Now that it is concrete, we think it is important to inform you as soon as possible and start the conversation about how we can shape this together in a good way. 

Why does the municipality of Aalten want a shelter?

Right now, there is a significant shortage of shelters nationwide. We want to take our social responsibility in this. We think it is important to offer a safe place to people who have had to leave everything behind because of war, discrimination or terror. We want to accommodate these people in a way that suits our municipality. In addition, on February 1, 2024, the Act "municipal task enabling asylum reception facilities" (Spreading Act) was passed. This law gave municipalities a legal duty to receive asylum seekers.

The Spread Law is not going to pass, is it? So why are you going to provide shelter for asylum seekers?

The Spreads Act is in effect until government and parliament formally repeal it. It is unclear whether that will happen and possibly by when. 

In the Achterhoek region we have to provide 1,691 asylum reception places. Before the law went into effect, we were already working on finding shelter for asylum seekers. After all, good reception remains necessary; there will always be people who flee because of the unsafe situation in their homeland. Therefore, as the Achterhoek region and as a municipality, we take our responsibility and want to contribute to solving the reception shortage. Therefore, we want to open a temporary location for the reception of asylum seekers.

Can I object to the arrival of the shelter?

You cannot object to the arrival of a shelter for asylum seekers in our municipality and its location.

COA must still apply for an environmental permit for the reception location. If this permit is granted, you can object to it. This is only possible if you have a fact-based interest in this decision. Distance to the location and the consequences of the location for you play a role.

Do you have questions about demonstration or protest action?

For more information, see Holding a demonstration or protest.

Questions about site selection

What other sites were in the picture and why were they dropped? (16-05-2025)

See also: Location choice COA Eerste Broekdijk and Singelweg in Aalten (page 19) and Research temporary housing Aalten (page 20 and further)

A total of seven locations were investigated. Six were rejected, in Dinxperlo the ice rink and a location on the business park and in Aalten the old ice rink, two locations on 't Kobus and a location on the Eerste Broekdijk. They were dropped because they did not sufficiently meet the criteria set by both the municipality and COA:

  • the site must be available quickly and for a longer period of time. This means preferably owned by the municipality, or at least rented for a longer period of time.
  • size location is larger than 3,000 m2 (which is the minimum size for COA for a shelter with 100 to 150 reception places).
  • temporary housing can land in one larger or several small locations. Both have advantages and disadvantages.
  • the site must connect to the public road.
  • utility connections can be made prior to completion.
  • the site is not part of regular plan stock for permanent housing.
  • the location is in/near a core, near amenities and/or accessible by public transportation.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 




Why not several smaller shelters scattered throughout the municipality?

COA indicates that they can only fully organize reception locations of 300 persons or more, including supervision, security, care and day care. For smaller reception locations, the municipality must largely arrange this itself. This requires much effort from, for example, general practitioners, volunteers and other local facilities, and also involves higher costs. The council has therefore opted for one central location for a maximum of 300 asylum seekers. This is currently the most feasible and practicable option.

Why did the municipality choose this location?

In recent months, the municipality has been working with COA to find a suitable location for realizing a reception site for asylum seekers. The location on the Singelweg in Aalten is the only location that has been assessed by COA as suitable for development in the short term. 

The land is owned by the municipality and the site is conveniently located to infrastructure and amenities. The location near a residential area is also a positive point. This encourages the integration of asylum seekers into the local community and enables them to build a social network.

Who owns the land?

The municipality of Aalten owns the land where the shelter is to be located.

How long will the shelter stay in this location?

The shelter can be operated for 10 years.

What will happen in ten years? Will the shelter disappear then?

After ten years, the site will become available for regular housing development. It will then no longer be a reception site for asylum seekers.

Questions about asylum reception

What is the role of COA?

The Central Agency for the Reception of Asylum Seekers (COA) is responsible for receiving asylum seekers and guiding them to a future within or outside the Netherlands. Both COA and municipalities look for suitable locations for new reception centers.

The reception location to be established in the municipality of Aalten is intended for asylum seekers who must wait for their asylum application to be decided or have already completed the general asylum procedure but have not yet been assigned housing. Here they will receive shelter, food and medical and legal support during the asylum procedure. They also get a start on their civic integration and, where possible, are guided to gainful employment.

How does the asylum procedure work in the Netherlands?

This video on youtube explains how the asylum procedure works. The video is from the Central Agency for the Reception of Asylum Seekers (COA) and can be found on Youtube. COA is responsible for the reception and guidance of asylum seekers in the Netherlands.

Video of asylum procedure

Does the shelter affect me as a resident of the municipality of Aalten?

The impact that the stay of asylum seekers has on residents of a municipality varies greatly. Those living in the immediate vicinity naturally notice more of their presence. For other residents this will remain limited. Of course, everyone experiences the presence of asylum seekers differently. Asylum seekers are free to go wherever they want. Thus, they will explore the neighborhood, do their shopping in the local supermarket and will visit stores in the center. As a rule, contact is smooth and without significant problems. Residents can also make contact with asylum seekers themselves; involving them in daily affairs as well as all kinds of leisure activities. Asylum seekers are only too happy to welcome such initiatives! 

Where a nuisance is experienced, it can always be reported immediately to the site manager.

How many asylum seekers are coming?

The shelter can accommodate up to 300 residents.

When will the first residents arrive?

It is expected that the shelter can be completed in 2027. When the first residents will arrive we cannot say at this time.

What target groups will live there: singles or families?

We do not know at this time who will be living at the shelter. It depends on the influx at that time. The background of the refugees is very different. This is because the influx of refugees in the Netherlands is also very different.

Can the municipality determine which target groups will be accommodated at the site?

The municipality has no role in this. The shelter is intended for asylum seekers who must wait for their asylum applications to be decided or have already completed the general asylum procedure, but have not yet been assigned housing. 

Who pays for the cost of the shelter location?

COA is responsible for the operation of the site and thus the costs.

Will the municipality receive money for enabling the shelter location?

Yes. Municipalities with a reception site receive money from the central government for this purpose. These allowances are an allowance for the additional costs incurred by municipalities.

What do shelter residents do during the day?

COA provides day care for the asylum seekers. The residents live and live independently in a reception location. They do their housework and take their children to school. They also prepare for their future with activities or volunteer work at the location. More information about activities at a reception location can be found on COA's website.

What will be regulated in terms of security?

There is 24-hour supervision at the shelter. The municipality is responsible for safety in public spaces. We take our responsibility and make agreements about this with COA, the police and other parties.

We also make a safety plan together with COA. This plan explains how we ensure that local residents can continue to live comfortably and safely, how we deal with nuisance and what we do to keep it to a minimum. We include in this the input gathered during meetings and residents' consultations and we use the experiences of other municipalities with asylum seekers' centers, such as Winterswijk. We will work out the safety plan before the first residents arrive at the reception location.

What facilities are there at the shelter?

COA provides the facilities and activities at the reception location. What kind of activities are organized and how the reception location is set up can be found on COA's website.

Is the shelter location publicly accessible?

The shelter is open to the public. Visitors must report to the reception desk. 

Questions about communication and participation

Why did the studies not take into account neighborhood support (16-05-2025)?

When choosing a reception location, practical, spatial and organizational conditions were primarily examined: is the location large enough, is there room for buildings and facilities, is it within reach of, for example, schools or sports fields, the train station, stores and so on. Support in the area is certainly important, but that is difficult to measure objectively in advance. That is why we are paying a great deal of attention to it: by informing local residents, engaging in dialogue and including concerns and ideas in the further development of the plans. 

How does the municipality engage residents?

There are several meetings where both local residents and other residents of the municipality will be informed about the plans and what's next. And where questions, concerns and ideas can be shared. In addition, the intention is to start a neighborhood consultation. The municipality will set this up to listen to the wishes from the neighborhood in order to achieve a good integration of the shelter in the neighborhood.

How does the municipality keep the area informed of important developments about the shelter site?

We would like to hear from the residents themselves what their needs are in this regard. Consider, for example, a newsletter or a residents' meeting/ sounding board group. This will be discussed during the meeting with local residents. 

Other questions

What about housing for our children? Shouldn't that be the priority? (16-05-2025)

The pressure on the housing market is indeed great. We often hear that young people and first-time buyers struggle to find housing, including in our municipality. That is why housing construction remains a high priority. Housing is being built or planned in several places, especially affordable housing.  

The reception of asylum seekers is separate from this. It is temporary reception, using flexible, relocatable housing at a separate location on Singelweg. The 40 homes intended for this purpose will be removed after 10 years, so that we can build new homes back on the existing infrastructure, or they will be rented to non-asylum seekers after 10 years.

In short: we are committed to both. We help people who need temporary shelter and continue to build for our own residents.

When are you a refugee, asylum seeker, status holder or unaccompanied minor? What target group does COA want to accommodate at Singelweg?

  • Refugees are people who fled their countries because it was too dangerous for them there. For example, because of war or violence.
  • Asylum seekers are refugees who have applied for asylum in the Netherlands. This means that they have asked to live here temporarily. They have applied to the Immigration and Naturalization Service (IND) for a residence permit to do so. While they are waiting for the residence permit, they live in an asylum seekers' center (azc) or in a temporary reception facility. This is the group we want to receive in Aalten later on.
  • Status holders are asylum seekers who have been granted residence status. They are eligible for housing within a municipality in the Netherlands.
  • AMV-ers are young refugees (boys and girls) between the ages of 15 and 18 who have sought asylum in the Netherlands without parents and guidance. They follow special programs and go to school during the day. COA helps them with structure and the first steps towards integration. Unaccompanied minor asylum seekers are received in reception locations specially designed for them.

Will my house be worth less because of the arrival of the shelter, and who will compensate?

Do you think your house will lose value because of the arrival of the shelter? Then you can ask for financial compensation. This is called loss compensation (formerly known as planning damage).

Damage compensation can be applied for after an environmental permit is issued. When exactly this is we cannot say at this time.

Each request for loss compensation is unique and is reviewed by independent consultants. The Municipality of Aalten has no role in or influence on the assessment. We do, however, make the final decision.

You can read more about loss compensation on ourloss compensationpage.

The Living Environment Information Point provides more detailed information on compensation for damages.

What is the municipality doing for its own residents seeking housing?

We believe it is important to have enough housing for our residents. In various places in our municipality, homes are being built or there are initiatives to build. The building is done by initiators, but we as a municipality also give out land. Besides the intended shelter location, we see room for permanent housing, especially for starters. The possibilities for this will be elaborated and realized simultaneously with the development of the reception location. 

Where can I ask questions, comments and complaints?

Until the site opens, please contact the municipality with any questions or comments. You can do so by calling our phone number 0543 49 33 33 or at opvang@aalten.nl. Once the location is up and running, it can be reached 24/7 via a phone number and email address. COA shares this information before the location opens.

Where can I report a demonstration or protest?

All information can be found at Holding a demonstration or protest.

Can I object?

You cannot object to the arrival of a shelter for asylum seekers in our municipality and its location.

COA must still apply for an environmental permit for the reception location. If this permit is granted, you can object to it. This is only possible if you have a fact-based interest in this decision. Distance to the location and the consequences of the location for you play a role.

We also received answers to the questions posed to us by residents during the meetings at the South Church (mid-May) and sent to us via email or post. 

We have divided the relevant questions and answers into 15 sections:

1. Safety

What do you guarantee for our safety? 

The safety of residents remains a priority. Absolute safety can never be guaranteed, just as it cannot be guaranteed in other situations (think traffic safety or crime). Therefore, together with COA, police and other partners, a safety plan is drawn up. This plan contains agreements on security, supervision and handling of incidents. A hotline will also be set up where you can report incidents 24/7.

If an AZC were to come, how would security be guaranteed? 

There will be 24/7 supervision at the location. Police, municipality and COA make agreements on cooperation, supervision and follow-up of reports outside the location. The district police officer will be involved in this. Neighbors can contribute to measures via the sounding board group. Experience at other AZCs shows that good agreements, supervision and communication ensure peace in the neighborhood.

Can safety be guaranteed? 

Complete safety can never be guaranteed, even without an AZC. What can: manage risks as well as possible. That is why there will be a security plan, tailored to the situation in Aalten. This will include agreements about supervision, the presence of security and following up on reports.

The site is directly adjacent to a young neighborhood with many children. How can safety be ensured here? 

This is precisely why additional measures are being taken. These include safe walking routes, clear information for local residents and visible security. There will also be a reporting point for nuisance. The safety of children and vulnerable groups receives extra attention in the safety plan.

What about safety on Estinea's own property? 

When drawing up the safety plan, surrounding areas such as that of Estinea will also be included. The municipality will discuss this with the organizations involved to make customized agreements that fit the local situation. We also take into account signals from care professionals.

Agreements on safety are recorded in a Safety Plan. Where does the municipality draw the line when agreements are not met? 

If the quality of life in the neighborhood is under pressure, if it turns out that COA does not know how to properly organize the reception and everything related to it, to name just a few examples.

What is being done and regulated around safety? 

We draw up a safety plan in advance, which also involves local residents (from the sounding board group). This means, for example, that we make agreements about the presence of security and, if necessary, make physical adjustments in the area (think of extra lighting). Following up complaints and nuisance reports is 'normal' police work. There will be extra surveillance and the neighborhood police officer will join the sounding board group.

Will residents soon have access to the safety plan? 

The safety plan is public and will be shared with the focus group and council in due course.

If the AZC actually comes there, how will security be ensured in the area, without turning the streetscape into something that looks like a prison and does not fit into this environment? 

Safety and livability go hand in hand. Measures such as good lighting and visibility are taken, but the basic principle is that the site should not have a closed or heavily secured appearance. It must fit into the environment. The safety plan will be coordinated with the environment through the sounding board group.

Will security be arranged? Also outside the shelter grounds? This relates to safety of Estinea night shift staff who also have to go outside at night when the alarm button is pressed. 

Yes, there will be 24/7 security on the site itself. Outside the site, the municipality will work with police for additional surveillance in the area. Employees on the night shift can count on support from this security. Agreements about this will be laid down in the security plan.

Already we hardly ever see police on the streets. Will the number of police officers be increased soon? Is there a plan for this? How will any nuisances be handled? Compensation for damages? 

The police are involved in drawing up the safety plan. That plan contains agreements about extra efforts in the neighborhood. Reports of nuisance are taken seriously and followed up. Damage to personal property can, as usual, be reported to the police. Damage to municipal property is handled by the municipality. Security on the grounds is the responsibility of COA.

Where will the (extra) agents be taken from, we already hardly ever see them? 

Our basic principle is that we receive asylum seekers who want to build a new life here, and that we are happy to help them do so. Should things go differently for some of them, we will deploy extra (police) capacity.

What are the experiences with incidents and how is security arranged at the AZC in Winterswijk? 

There is a 24/7 security presence in Winterswijk. As for incidents, these are mainly incidents on the location. This year there have been 4 incidents, 3 of which required an ambulance for a medical situation, and there has been 1 time a neighborhood police officer in connection with a mutual quarrel between 3 asylum seekers. There is regular consultation with local residents about safety and nuisance.

I read that there are 89% more incidents around AZCs, is that true? 

The figures are not recognized. Possibly it is about application sites like Ter Apel and Budel and emergency reception sites. In Aalten the plan is to realize a regular reception location and that is really different. Indeed, at a (large-scale) regular location, in addition to constant security, day care and education can be organized for the residents.
It is often also about a feeling of insecurity. We like to hear especially from local residents what concerns they have and what points of attention there are in the context of security. We include these in the safety plan and record them in agreements with COA. 

2. Supervision/supervision/security at the site

How much guidance is available from COA (number of guidance to number of asylum seekers)? 

At a regular location as proposed in Aalten, COA provides appropriate staffing. During the day, several supervisors and social workers are present. At night, 3 security guards are present. The number of staff is tailored to the group size (maximum 300) and is monitored by COA, with experience from other AZCs as a starting point.

How many security guards will soon be present? 

At night 3 security guards because no other supervisors are present then.
During the day 1 security guard because supervisors and other staff are present.

What happens to an asylum seeker who misbehaves? 

The latter is held accountable for this in the first instance. One possible measure is transfer to another asylum center.

What punishment will asylum seekers receive if they commit a crime? 

If charges are filed, Dutch criminal law also applies to them.
Nuisances and asylum seekers who misbehave are transferred to another AZC, in order to remove them from a particular environment. And sometimes they are transferred to a special shelter with more control and supervision.
The consequence may also be that the IND withdraws the permit for serious crimes. 

3. Housing market/ Housing value

What about decrease in property value (compensation)? 

Once an environmental permit has been granted for the shelter site, there is the possibility for homeowners to apply to the municipality for compensation for loss of value. This was previously referred to as plan damage.
The scheme is intended for situations in which the value of a home demonstrably decreases due to a spatial decision by the government, such as the establishment of an AZC. The request is assessed by an independent party.
There is no additional regulation or additional compensation from the municipality on top of the legal regulation. Also, compensation for decrease in value is not an issue at this time, as no permit has been granted yet.

Will the possible arrival of an AZC negatively affect the home value? (Does it even lead to unsaleability or to sale at a significantly lower value than the market value of the home) 

Concerns about this are understandable, but it is difficult to make general statements about housing value effects. These are different for each location and situation. As described in the answer to the previous question, there is a statutory scheme for compensation for loss of value if it is demonstrably caused by a government decision.

If an AZC were to be built, does the municipality have a plan to solve this financially, for example, by buying the houses in question itself in case the sale within a certain period of time (e.g. 3 months) at the 'normal' value does not succeed? And will the WOZ value also be adjusted by the municipality? 

No, the municipality does not have a supplementary scheme or buyout scheme. There is only the legal scheme for plan damage/damage compensation. The municipality does not purchase properties.
Regarding the WOZ value: it is not automatically adjusted. If you think your WOZ value is incorrect due to changed circumstances, you can object to it through the regular procedure.

To whom can I apply for compensation for decrease in the value of my property?

At the municipality. An external agency is called in to assess the difference between the old and new situation. It is then determined according to national policy whether there is a right to compensation (for example, no one is entitled to an unobstructed view from their home) and how much it is. A small percentage of the decrease in value is considered a homeowner's own risk.
Incidentally, a request cannot be made until the permit is granted.

Does the municipality, other than as required by law, provide compensation for diminished value of nearby homes? 

No, there is no provision for that now. 

4. Traffic safety & environment

What about traffic safety on Singelweg/Slaadreef, especially for pedestrians and cyclists?

Traffic safety will be explicitly included in the further development of the plan. This involves looking at safe walking and cycling routes, preventing cut-through traffic and limiting undesirable walking routes. This also applies to the situation around 't Slaa, where many children play outside. Complete closure of access roads is not foreseen at this time, but measures are being considered to limit traffic congestion and nuisance.

Why so close to a residential area? There are no stores here, transportation etc. will still have to be arranged to the center. 

The expectation is that the distance is such that asylum seekers can reach it on their own by bicycle - and possibly walking. Where necessary, COA will provide mobility support.  

The location is not very close to the center of Aalten and on a busy main road. Doesn't that create traffic unsafe situations? 

The asylum seekers will mainly walk and bike towards the center (station, stores). At the main road they will in principle not come. We also take this form of safety into account when filling in the location.

What about noise pollution at the site? Will there be a sound barrier and will it be sufficient? 

Even for this development, we simply have to and want to meet all the requirements, including those related to noise pollution. We will take that into account in the infill or take measures for that.

What is the municipality doing about traffic safety in places where pedestrians cross, such as the Hameland route? 

Traffic safety is an important part of the development plan. Safe walking and biking routes to and from the shelter, clear crosswalks and any additional measures to prevent people from simply crossing the road will be considered.

Will the access road to residential area 't Slaa be closed, including to cyclists and pedestrians? 

Completely closing the access road, including to cyclists and pedestrians, has major consequences for accessibility - including for residents themselves. Therefore, a balance is being sought between accessibility and countering inconvenience. It is not yet clear where and how many access roads there will eventually be. However, measures can be taken that discourage unwanted traffic or walking routes, without closing off the neighborhood unnecessarily. 

5. Administrative & democratic process

How can you decide this without first consulting with local residents? 

The municipality came forward as soon as it was clear that the Singelweg site was both suitable and available. Before that, a careful study was made of the possible locations. Earlier communication could have led to unnecessary unrest about locations that ultimately would not be chosen. Now that there is a concrete plan, room has been made for discussions with the surrounding area, including meetings and a sounding board group.

Why can't we object? 

At this time, no formal decision has been made to which objection is possible. Once an environmental permit is requested, a legal procedure will follow in which interested parties can submit views. This will be published at that time, so that anyone who wishes to do so can make a formal response.

Does the Board of Mayor and Aldermen have the authority to use land designated for housing development for asylum reception? 

Yes, the college is authorized to make proposals on the use of municipal land. In this case, there is not yet an established zoning plan for residential development at this location. The college proposes to change the zoning to "residential" and then make it temporarily available for reception of asylum seekers.

How are all responses/questions collected? 

During the meetings, all questions will be noted and be online and questions can still be submitted. All questions will be collected, compiled and answered at this location on the municipal website. Input from the focus group will also be included in the process.

Will I be informed when the spatial procedure starts? 

Yes. As soon as the spatial procedure (such as an application for an environmental permit) starts, this will be published. Local residents and anyone who has signed up for the newsletter will also be informed. There is then also an opportunity to submit views.

Where is democracy in this process? 

The college has decided on the site and is submitting it as a proposal to the council;a council democratically elected by residents. The council ultimately decides. Members of the city council also attend the meetings to hear what is going on.

The council will soon give a binding opinion. Will the college abide by it? 

Yes.

Are there any opportunities to adjust the process towards the council? 

Yes. Until the City Council has issued its opinion, there is room for residents to express their views. This can be done in writing or orally, for example by speaking at a council meeting. Signals collected at the meetings or are also shared with the city council.

Has the City Council been informed of the location, plans for asylum shelter? 

Yes, the sites that were examined were shared with the council in confidence and any other suitable sites were requested. The decision for the Singel 2 site, the maximum number of asylum seekers to be received of 300 and the duration of up to 10 years was made by the college, not the council.

Why was the decision not postponed until after the municipal elections? 

The reception task is urgent and the process cannot be postponed indefinitely. Moreover, there is the dispersal law, which requires each municipality to contribute to reception by a certain date. The council now involved is democratically elected and has previously given direction to this process through motions and questions. The city council is also now expressly involved in the decision-making process.

There is an asylum crisis, is the college now ignoring all the procedures and the role of the council? 

No. The college prepares a decision and submits it to the council. The college may opt for an abbreviated procedure because it is a temporary shelter, but the college expressly does not choose that. 

6. Spreading law & numbers

The national government intends to repeal the dispersion law. It is then a strange thing that the municipality still wants to apply the spreading law in Aalten now. Why do this now? 

The spreading law is currently still in effect and municipalities are required to comply with it. Whether and when the law will be repealed is unclear. Moreover, the college feels a social responsibility to contribute to a humane and workable reception of people in need of protection. Even without a dispersal law, shelters will continue to be needed.

Why does the municipality want to comply with the spreading law at all? 

Some 96,000 reception places for asylum seekers are needed in the Netherlands. As a municipality we want to take our social responsibility towards the refugees who ask for help in the Netherlands as well as towards the other municipalities where asylum seekers are received. Moreover: the dispersal law is still in force and is not expected to be abolished any time soon.

According to the dispersal law, Aalten must accommodate 157 people. At the Knobo, 80 asylum seekers have already been housed. How can the difference with the number of 300 be explained? 

The Knobo location does not house asylum seekers, but Ukrainian refugees. Based on the dispersal law, the state initially allocated Aalten 157 reception places. They too are fleeing war violence, but have a different residence status and do not have to go through an asylum procedure. By the end of 2024, regional agreements increased this to 200. The municipality is now opting for one stable reception location with a maximum of 300 asylum seekers because COA only provides full support in the areas of security, day care, care and guidance above that number.

Why does the municipality want to host 300 asylum seekers? 

The college chooses a location for a maximum of 300 asylum seekers because there will be support, day care, 24/7 security and care available at the site. In this way justice can be done to the concerns of local residents about issues such as safety, nuisance and preventing overburdening of local care .

Commitment is 200 asylum seekers (that was 157, right?), so why does the municipality want to accommodate 300? 

See the answer to the questions above. The task has been adjusted from 157 to 200 on the basis of regional agreements. The choice for 300 is deliberate: it offers better on-site support, which benefits peace, safety and livability for the residents of Aalten and the residents of the AZC.

What are the consequences for the municipality of Aalten if the spreading law is not met? 

If a municipality does not meet the task, the government can give an instruction to still provide shelter. In doing so, the local right of decision lapses. By fulfilling the assignment itself, the municipality of Aalten retains control over location, scale and integration.

What if the dispersal law expires, will the municipality proceed with plans for asylum shelter? 

Yes. The college has indicated its willingness to assume its responsibility even without a legal obligation. The reception need remains, regardless of the status of the law. This is not only a legal obligation, but also solidarity with other municipalities, humane reception and regional agreements. 

7. Site selection & alternatives

Why not a venue with 50 people? Or 100? 

The college chooses a location for up to 300 asylum seekers because then COA can ensure that maximum support, day care, security and care is available at the location. In this way justice can be done to the concerns of local residents. At locations smaller than 300 reception places, COA can only partially provide that care; many small locations exceed COA's service capacity.

Why is the shelter not spread across multiple locations in the municipality? 

Scattered shelters seem attractive, but in practice they have disadvantages. Small locations often lack guidance, day care and 24/7 supervision, which leads to more unrest. At one location of 300 people, COA can provide full security, day care and supervision.

Why not look at other locations, such as where Dorcas sits? 

This site is not owned by the municipality and therefore does not meet any of the important conditions. Owned sites are preferred so that quick and careful action can be taken.

Why is only this location suitable? 

Seven sites were examined. Consideration was given to land availability, accessibility, safety, ownership, distance from homes and facilities. The site on Singelweg scored highest on all these points and was found to be the only suitable one.

Kobus 1 and Kobus 2 were apparently dropped in the assessment of potentially suitable sites. Does this mean they are now eligible for housing development? 

That is not yet known; we will take it as a tip.

One of the conditions for a site is that it not be on a housing site. So why here? 

The council's motion regarding Singel 1 and 2 was to investigate the sites for housing opportunities. The council has started to do that. At the same time, there is a reception task from the dispersal law. The site is still zoned "agricultural" and is not part of the regular plan supply for housing. That is why at Singel 2 it was decided to combine both tasks: first temporary housing for a maximum of 10 years, then regular housing.

How does the municipality turn from "no AZC" to a full AZC in such a short period of time? 

Indeed, in 2022, the council took a different position. Since then, the national situation has changed. The dispersal law is in effect and the regional shelter requirement has been increased. The council wants to keep direction on choice of location, facilities and timeliness. By organizing this itself, better justice can be done to community concerns. And at a fully-fledged reception location (from 300 reception places) COA is fully responsible for reception, housing security and services.

Why not choose alternative locations such as camping 't Walfort? 

This site is not owned by the municipality and therefore does not meet the requirements for quick and secure availability. Ownership is an important criterion in the site study.

What if soon there is a housing plan for this location? Will the shelter continue then? 

Yes, as long as the reception assignment and agreements with COA are in place, the site will remain in use as a reception location. The housing plans will be realized after the expiration of the temporary reception period of up to 10 years. The two functions will therefore be completed one after the other. 

8. Reception time & future plans

What does shelter mean for 10 years? Can the municipality give guarantees about this? 

Yes. The reception location will be made available for a maximum of 10 years. This maximum period is laid down in the college decision, is reflected in the Administrative Agreement with COA and is also legally secured in the environmental plan. After those 10 years, the site will be redeveloped into housing. These agreements cannot be changed unilaterally.

How can we be sure that the AZC will actually disappear after 10 years? 

The municipality has included the maximum term of 10 years in the decision and will make binding agreements with COA in an administrative agreement. After that period, the site will be used for regular housing development.

The college says "a maximum of 300 asylum seekers. What if it does become more, like in Ter Apel? 

The situation here is really different. In Ter Apel they can't decide how many asylum seekers are coming, they have to take in every refugee who reports. In Aalten, COA will soon determine who comes to live in the reception, no unannounced asylum seekers come there.
The agreement of a maximum of 300 asylum seekers will be laid down in the Administrative Agreement.

Why 10 years? And not 5 or 15 years? 

The 10-year term is the result of careful consideration. COA requires that reception locations be available for at least 10 years so that investments in above-ground and underground infrastructure, buildings, security and facilities can be recouped. At the same time, it is important for the municipality to be able to guarantee the temporary nature. Therefore, this bounded period was chosen.

At what point does the 10-year term start? 

From the moment the first asylum seeker is housed at the site.

It has been indicated that after 10 years of shelter, the site will be "converted" to a residential area with regular housing. How should I picture that? 

The idea is to immediately align the layout as much as possible with the future housing development. Think about road structure and public space. We can use that structure again, saving costs and speeding up the transition to housing.  

The college guarantees that the shelter is for a maximum of 10 years. In 10 years these directors will no longer be there, can it still be extended? 

The maximum period of 10 years is legally laid down in the Administrative Agreement between the municipality and COA as well as in the zoning decree. This means that the agreement cannot simply be extended, even by a subsequent college. 

9. Collection form & capacity

How do you arrive at the number of 300 people? 

Based on the Dispersal Act, the national government has given the municipality of Aalten a task of 157 reception places. Regional agreements have adjusted this to 200, which has also become the legal obligation. The college now opts for a location for a maximum of 300 persons because from that number COA offers full support in the areas of security, day care, care and guidance. This ensures more peace and structure for residents and the environment.

Is the plan to accommodate families or loners or a combination? 

It is a combination of families and adults traveling alone. No unaccompanied minors are accommodated. COA determines the exact composition based on the reception need and looks at appropriate combinations upon placement.

What people will live there, in what composition? 

This depends on the situation in the world at the time of opening. The municipality's influence in this is very limited.

Eight people in one home, people who don't know each other and may have been traumatized, that can't go well, can it? 

The shelter is not luxurious, but frugal and effective. COA's program of requirements is in line with European regulations. Reception of eight persons per house is already applied in other locations, such as Winterswijk, and is considered workable there.
The placement takes into account background, culture and family composition. For trauma care, a family doctor and a mental health practitioner are available on site.

Eight people in a home; is that eight random strangers who have to live and live with each other? 

No. COA looks at who fits together in the composition of housing units, for example on the basis of language, culture or family situation. People who cannot live together are not placed in the same housing unit. Counseling is also provided to help manage living together.

Do single young people (up to 18 years old) also come to the shelter in Aalten? 

No. There are special shelters for that in other places in the Netherlands. In Aalten, only adults and families traveling alone are received. 

10. Cultural integration & society

Does selection by language and/or culture take place? 

No, there is no selection by language or culture. COA determines who will be placed where on the basis of national reception capacity and family composition. We do look at who can live well together, for example in terms of age, background or family situation. Upon arrival, but also on location, residents are educated about norms and values in the Netherlands.  

Accommodating 300 asylum seekers in a relatively small location is asking for trouble, isn't it? (Different cultures, beliefs and ways of thinking about relationships between men and women, different norms and values) 

Cultural differences are recognized. That is why there is daily supervision at the location and residents are actively informed about Dutch values, norms and manners. Attention is also paid to interaction between residents and with the neighborhood. Supervisors and volunteers play an important role in this, as do day care and structure in daily life.

How is it ensured that the arrival of a large group of people from different cultural backgrounds does not lead to a loss of local norms and values, tensions in the neighborhood or a decline in mutual trust in fellow human beings? 

Asylum seekers are educated about life in the Netherlands, including our norms and values. They are supervised by COA employees and can participate in day care, language education and volunteer activities. COA strives for an open, small-scale and accessible reception structure. By keeping residents occupied and encouraging contact with the neighborhood, the likelihood of tensions is reduced. This has proven successful in other municipalities.

Asylum seekers come from a different culture, where sometimes people with disabilities are also viewed differently. Is this taken into account? 

In general, there is a lot of explanation and attention to Dutch values and norms, both on arrival and on location. We can imagine that there is extra attention to this concern, and that we make arrangements for asylum seekers to be constantly informed about it.

Do asylum seekers want to integrate? Nationwide, there is a lot of crime in municipalities with an AZC. 

Incidents are often widely reported in the media, which does give a distorted picture. Moreover, it is often about Ter Apel (with a really different function / other residents) and about "old" AZCs where there is hardly any integration with other residents. COA indicates that locations with an open structure (no fences and barrier), different layout and other buildings show different figures. The facilities at the AZC, such as the day care offered by COA, also have a positive effect on the well-being of residents and neighbors.

Integration is important, but how are 300 people kept busy on site? 

Children go to school, adults take language classes, have conversations and appointments around their asylum applications, participate in activities (day care), volunteer or go to work.

The asylum seekers all have different cultures and beliefs; are appropriate social workers available for them? 

We have already received offers from several quarters of volunteers who are willing and able to contribute to this, also to help ease any mutual tensions.

Asylum seekers are criminalized beforehand, which is not justified, right? 

Incidents that happen are often widely reported in the media, which gives this - indeed not correct - image about all asylum seekers. There are people, from different backgrounds present at a location, and of course that sometimes creates tensions. What is important is that people are kept busy. This is done by COA, but also volunteers (groups) can have a role in this (in Winterswijk some 35 volunteers are active). It is too early to say whether volunteer work will soon be coordinated by COA or, for example, by Figulus. For now, people who want to sign up for this may do so through opvang@aalten.nl.

Fear cramps, trust gives room. What can we as residents do?  

Residents can make an important contribution to welcoming and integration. Consider volunteering, helping with activities or simply engaging in conversation. Signals of concerns or bottlenecks are also valuable. Anyone who wants to do something can report to the municipality or email opvang@aalten.nl.

How does this benefit the environment? 

Active AZC residents are less prone to boredom or nuisance and can give something back to society. Informal contacts between local residents and AZC residents also develop more often, for example through sports clubs or volunteer projects. This helps promote integration and mutual understanding. 

11. Care & education

What are the implications for general practitioners (healthcare)? 

One of the things COA arranges for in a shelter of the intended size is that a doctor is available at the site.  

National figures show that about 40% of care requests can be solved at the shelter. What about the rest?

Nationwide, the rest of the care questions still come to the family doctors, and if necessary to the hospital/specialists or mental health care. This would be an issue that we would want to fine tune in advance, and also establish in the Administrative Agreement.

Health care is available at the site. Does that include mental health care? 

A Practice Support Physician (POH) for mental health care is available at the location, as with our primary care physicians. For more severe care, regular mental health services are called in.

Will asylum seekers get priority for mental health care? 

No. Initially, they rely on care available at the site. So that is separate from care providers in the municipality. For severe mental health problems, asylum seekers, like us, come on the waiting list.

Are there opportunities to collaborate in the delivery of care? 

Yes, COA cooperates with GZA (Health Care Asylum Seekers), which is responsible for providing on-site medical care. Where possible, regional healthcare partners are involved. The Administrative Agreement includes agreements on coordination with local healthcare providers. There is also room for cooperation in the areas of prevention, vaccination and counseling.

Is there enough staff (to be found) at the location? 

Several more agreements and plans will be made (safety plan, as well as others). These will always include a paragraph, "How can we recruit enough staff for...".

There is a shortage of healthcare staff, so how does COA get enough staff? 

The GZA (Health Care Asylum Seekers) provides staff at an AZC. There are national agreements on availability of doctors, nurses and practice support workers. Currently, GZA has no structural shortage and ensures that residents receive appropriate care in a timely manner.

Will there be a school / is there education at the site? 

The idea now is that space will also be reserved for education at the service buildings, but exactly what that would look like is not yet known.
Educational needs are coordinated with the municipality and the primary and secondary school partnerships. In many cases, children attend schools in the region.

Is dental care available for residents? 

There is no dentist permanently present at the AZC itself. COA organizes dental care through the national health care organization (Health Care Asieslzoekers, GZA). Children up to 18 years of age receive regular dental care. Adults receive emergency care only. The required capacity is determined by contract.

Are children being vaccinated? 

Asylum seekers are screened by the Public Health Service upon arrival. Children up to age 18 are voluntarily offered the vaccinations that are also in the National Vaccination Program (such as mumps, measles and rubella). Vaccination is not mandatory, but willingness to cooperate is usually high. 

12. COA/municipal responsibility

Is the municipality doing this just for the money? Does it also benefit our neighborhood? 

The premise is that the realization of an AZC is cost-neutral. COA receives funding from the state for the reception of asylum seekers; the municipality does not receive compensation per person received. However, national compensation is available, for example for extra costs for youth care, education or quality of life.
The neighborhood can benefit indirectly because COA invests in good facilities, lighting and safety, and in time new housing will be built at the location for which the infrastructure is already in place.

What if the Administrative Agreement is not fulfilled by COA? What if, for example, the maximum number of asylum seekers present is exceeded? 

Agreements on this are also laid down in advance in the Administrative Agreement. Consider the penalty clause that applies in Ter Apel if the number of asylum seekers present is exceeded. A similar agreement can also apply to 'security'.

COA is responsible for site safety; can they deliver? 

Yes. Security guards are hired for this purpose (there is 24/7 security at the site). At the AZC in Winterswijk, people are very satisfied with the security. There is a good and close team and the lines are short. Of course things happen sometimes, but it is manageable.  

The college chooses to accommodate 300 asylum seekers, or in other words the responsibility is completely shifted to COA? 

No. The municipality remains responsible for the proper functioning of the reception location within its municipal boundaries, and therefore works closely with COA. Tasks are divided: COA is responsible for implementation at the location (security, guidance, care), the municipality for matters such as safety in the neighborhood, supervision, coordination with local residents and planning decisions.

So what will be stipulated in the Administrative Agreement between the municipality and COA? 

Answer:
In any case:
- Which target group will be accommodated (families and single travelers 18+)
- The maximum number of 300 asylum seekers
- The maximum duration of 10 years
- Agreements on safety, day care, care and guidance
- Communication and consultation with local residents
- Agreements on 24/7 telephone accessibility, monitoring, complaints and evaluation
The agreements will be legally recorded at a later date, with appendices for concrete working agreements and evaluation moments. 

13. Finance & Costs

What will it all cost? 

The shelter will be built and paid for by COA. This means that construction, furnishing, supervision and operation are not borne by the municipality. The municipality may have costs for things outside the site, such as extra public lighting or supervision in the area.
There is also no earning model for the municipality. Any reimbursements from the state are intended to cover costs arising from additional efforts in areas such as youth care, education or quality of life.

Does the municipality receive compensation per asylum seeker to be received? 

No. COA receives money from the state per bed occupied. At 300 beds, COA can also provide facilities at the location. At smaller locations, this allowance is not sufficient, nor can additional facilities (such as day care and security) be provided.

Does it make the municipality money to accommodate asylum seekers? 

The shelter is realized and paid for by COA, they receive money for it from the state. The municipality does not.
If, for safety reasons, extra efforts are needed outside the location or, for example, extra lighting has to be installed, these costs will be borne by the municipality.
We do want to agree with COA that they will take into account the situation after 10 years, so that we as the municipality will have to incur fewer costs.

Are there any (financial) benefits to the municipality and/or the district? 

There are no direct financial benefits for the municipality. However, the neighborhood and the municipality can benefit from investments in infrastructure, lighting or livability that are realized at the same time as the arrival of the AZC. Also, local businesses and organizations can be involved in supplies, services or counseling, providing indirect economic benefits.

Is there a revenue model for COA or the municipality?

 COA needs a minimum period of 10 years to recoup investments in buildings, security and facilities. This is a practical precondition and not a commercial profit objective. The municipality receives no compensation per asylum seeker and acts out of social responsibility. Compensation from the state is only available for demonstrable costs, such as youth care, education or quality of life. 

14. Work & Participation

Are asylum seekers allowed to work? 

Yes, that is allowed as part of their integration into Dutch society. From the AZC in Winterswijk, projects have been started for this purpose with five companies.

What is the motivation for asylum seekers to work when the flow is 6 months to a year? 

Starting work in advance is very good for integration. As soon as someone gets a status (and is allowed to stay in the Netherlands), he/she already has a head start and can quickly start working again.

Can't we take in more status holders instead of 200 or 300 asylum seekers? At least they are allowed to work and can really contribute something to our society. 

Asylum seekers are now also allowed to work. Winterswijk has already started projects for this, so that we can gain experience and also experience how integration can have a place in it. The housing of status holders is also a legal task that we as a municipality must meet, in which we adhere to the numbers specified by the government.

Are there projects in which asylum seekers are already participating in work or volunteering?

 Yes, COA works with companies and volunteer organizations on meaningful day care. In Winterswijk, projects have started with five companies where asylum seekers can participate under supervision. In Aalten, too, this type of pathway is being prepared.

Are the asylum seekers kept busy during the day? 

Yes. The situation in Winterswijk as an example: 

  • Children ages 1 to 4 attend daycare.
  • Older children attend primary or secondary school (within 3 months of arrival).
  • Adults take language classes (mandatory for status holders), work or are otherwise active during the day. 

15. Communication & Involvement

When will the focus group start? 

The plan is to convene the sounding board group of local residents once the City Council has agreed on a location.

Is there consultation with local residents? 

Yes, in the run-up to realization there is a sounding board group for local residents where concerns and questions are discussed and, for example, the security plan is also coordinated.
And there will also be regular contact / consultation after the first asylum seekers have moved in. Here too we follow the example of Winterswijk, where good experiences have been gained with this.

Can participants in the Estinea meeting also sit on the focus group? 

Yes, that is even desirable. Because some of the questions and concerns from Estinea are very specific, it is desirable to have an 'Estinea sounding board group' in addition where these specific questions and concerns are discussed. The municipality will take the initiative for this.

Are Singel 1 and Singel 2 connected? 

No. The idea now is that the areas will be developed individually (there is also a green belt between them), but the spatial procedure will be done simultaneously.

What can we as residents do?  

Lots. You can sign up for the focus group, contribute ideas about day care or safety, or be involved as a volunteer. Sharing concerns, ideas and initiatives helps to work together to create a livable environment for everyone. The municipality and COA are open to involvement, precisely because trust is essential for a good integration.

Why were Aalten residents not involved in this process earlier? 

Only when it became clear that this site was suitable and available could discussions with the surrounding area begin. Before that time, there was a risk of unrest about sites that ultimately would not be it.  

In what way will the AZC be included in the Environment Act? 

The arrival of the AZC is included in the spatial procedure and zoning change. The Environment Act also requires municipalities to involve residents in the development of the living environment. Your input will therefore be included in the decision-making process, including through the sounding board group and views during procedures.

Is there any way to still adjust the decision? 

Yes. No final decision has been made on the AZC. The City Council has yet to make a decision. Your input - at meetings or in writing - will be collected and included in that process.

Will there be a hotline for nuisances or questions? 

Yes. There will be a hotline for local residents where concerns or reports can be relayed. Exact details will be announced before the shelter actually starts.